Criminal Law Masters of the Courtroom Attorney in Minneapolis, Minnesota

Can I Talk to my Prosecutor?

More In This Category

View Transcript

It’s funny, I’m in the court all the time, and I see people do this and I think it’s a huge mistake. And the reason is at that stage in the procedure you don’t know, for the most part, what the prosecutor has against you. You don’t know what the police reports say, you don’t know what witnesses have told the police, and so when you go talk to the prosecutor you are giving them your story. And that’s the story you’re going to have to stick with because you are talking to the prosecutor you can’t suddenly change the story later. So if you are able to hire an attorney you should do that at the first moment.

Minneapolis criminal lawyer, Ryan Garry, answers whether you should talk to the prosecutor before hiring counsel. He observes that many individuals make a critical mistake by speaking directly with the prosecutor early in the process. At that stage, defendants often have little to no knowledge of the evidence against them, including police reports or witness statements. By offering their version of events prematurely, they risk locking themselves into a narrative that cannot later be changed without damaging credibility. He emphasizes that the wiser course is to retain an attorney as early as possible to protect one’s rights and ensure an informed defense strategy.

More Videos From This Lawyer